Features
The Bulletin
Books
Comics
Commentary
Gaming
Movies
Music
In Joe Hill’s second novel, Horns, Iggy Perrish awakens one morning to find he has two horns growing out of his head. He soon discovers that the horns have strange effects on his fellow citizens in Gideon, New Hampshire: they are not alarmed by the horns, but they do find themselves compelled to tell Iggy their deepest, darkest sins and desires. One might expect this newfound power to give Iggy a perverse pleasure as he discovers the secrets of his friends, family, and neighbors; however, there is a catch—everyone’s worst feelings seem to involve Iggy.
The growth of these horns caps off a bad year for Iggy: his longtime girlfriend, Merrin, had been raped and murdered 12 months before, and Iggy was the primary suspect, though the police could not make the case stick. Nonetheless, the entire community thinks he’s guilty, and most of their desires involve seeing Iggy suffer some kind of incredibly painful punishment. These desires extend to Iggy’s friends and family, who Iggy had thought were his only supporters, and his attempts to find some support or help for his condition lead him to discover the truth about Merrin’s murder.
Hill sets up some fairly simple rules for Iggy’s newfound powers. People can see the horns, but they don’t find them at all disturbing or odd. They do, however, completely forget they talked to Iggy once he leaves, so they don’t know that he heard their dark confessions. In addition, touching a person gives Iggy a glimpse into their past. Iggy can also use the horns to compel people to act on their desires, but since many of the people he meets desire to cause him harm, this power does not come in as handy as one might expect.
Other abilities and limitations make themselves known as the novel progresses, but much of the novel’s perverse appeal comes from Iggy’s ability to elicit these confessions. Iggy discovers that everyone harbors some dark secret, and these secrets have often had a negative effect on Iggy’s life: his parents and grandmother secretly think he’s guilty of killing his girlfriend, and his local priest wishes him considerable harm. Hill builds on these revelations not only to tell an effective supernatural mystery story, as Iggy uses his powers to exact revenge on Merrin’s killer, but also to make a larger commentary on hypocrisy and morality.
And it is in this larger commentary that the novel reaches a bit too far and eliminates the subtlety that could make this a great book. The novel’s argument, that the devil makes a stronger model for morality than hypocritical Christians who use their faith to promote their own selfish ends and make others suffer, has some fun potential. However, Hill almost stops the novel dead in its tracks by having Iggy deliver his own version of the fire sermon which lays this inversion out in specific detail, and that shows a decided lack of trust in the reader. Hill has already succeeded in making Iggy a likeable character with whom the reader has an investment, and that alone should have been enough to accomplish these thematic goals.
But that’s just a minor quibble, because the novel is otherwise compulsively, perversely entertaining, especially as Iggy becomes more comfortable in using his powers to get revenge on those who harmed him and killed his girlfriend. The novel’s narrative structure alternates between the contemporary story of Iggy’s transformation into a devil and flashbacks to Iggy’s relationship with Merrin up until her murder. The flashbacks are, perhaps, less compelling than the contemporary story, but they do help to build the reader’s sympathy for Iggy. They are, however, weakest when providing the back story for the novel’s villain, Lee Tourneau. Hill has the opportunity to create an effective, subtle villain in Lee, but he overplays his hand too much to ensure that readers dislike the character.
In its basic concept, the novel owes something to the magical realism of Gabriel Garcia Marquez and Salman Rushdie (it owes a lot, in fact, to The Satanic Verses in terms of the theme of moral inversion) as filtered through novelists like Neil Gaiman, Terry Pratchett, and Christopher Moore. Horns is a promising second novel, though it would be nice to see Hill embrace the subtlety and ambiguity of Rushdie and Marquez while retaining the irony and humor of his other influences.