Cop Out
What do you get when you add Bruce Willis, Tracy Morgan, and director Kevin Smith to a buddy-cop formula? A pretty frustrating experience, actually.

There’s a scene early in Cop Out—the second half of the first one, actually—that’ll tell you right away how you’re going to get along with the rest of it. Crazy (but apparently smart) detective Paul Hodges (Tracy Morgan) coerces his partner Jimmy Monroe (Bruce Willis) into letting him take the lead in the interrogation of a low-level flunky in a drug empire. Paul enters the room and proceeds to rip off lines from probably a dozen different movies while Jimmy, on the other side of the one-way glass, lists off what it is Paul is referencing. This is tedious enough by itself, but the staging—extreme close-ups on Morgan shticking intercut with shots of Willis listing off movie titles while looking off-camera, up against a blank brick wall—takes the tedious and sinks it into the realm of the inept. Cop Out never recovers.
The scene is curious for another reason: only it and one or two other jokes bear the distinct voice of Kevin Smith, who in Cop Out is directing his first movie written by someone else. I would call the rest of the film “rote,” but it does not even put that much work in; Cop Out assumes you have seen as many buddy-cop movies as its creators have, and allows that shared cultural knowledge to do most of the work.
In brief: Paul and Jimmy majorly botch an investigation into a drug ring operating in Brooklyn. They’re suspended for one month (complete with gun-and-badge turn-in) without pay, which sucks for Jimmy, who’s looking for a way to fund his daughter’s extravagant wedding. (It never occurs to him to tell his daughter that a $50,000 wedding may be somewhat exorbitant.) Paul thinks his wife is cheating on him. And when Jimmy tries to sell a rare baseball card to fund the wedding, he finds himself involved with the drug ring again. Which is certainly one way to have your B-plot loop back into your A-plot.
There’s also some business with a tweaker cat burglar (Seann William Scott) and some rival detectives (Kevin Pollak and Adam Brody), but they exist only to remind everyone how much funnier Cop Out should be.
And it should be. This is a jokey buddy-cop movie starring Tracy Morgan and Bruce Willis. Morgan’s made a name for himself doing exactly this kind of shtick on Saturday Night Live and 30 Rock, and Bruce Willis epitomizes the cop movie of the last 20 years. And though Smith has been trending downward since Chasing Amy, even the otherwise-abysmal Clerks 2 had some funny moments amid the dreadfully aimless scatology.
Some of the blame lies with writers Robb and Mark Cullen, no doubt, who together have a mostly unremarkable track record writing mostly unremarkable television. There is nothing special about this script, its people or its dialogue; it’s hard to imagine that anyone at any point in the film’s development process felt enthusiastic about it. The film’s tortured history—several roster changes both behind and in front of the camera--speaks clearly to that.
And that raises the question: if you’re going to pick Kevin Smith to do one of the two things he does for your movie, why on God’s green earth would you want him to direct? Smith’s movies are infamous for being of the “point the camera at the talking people” school of directing; it was always the dialogue that kept his work afloat. But no, in Cop Out we have the funny writer directing and the unfunny guys writing. Whose idea of success was that? If only Cop Out had kept its working title Dicks. That, at least, is clever.
The Wolfman
The remake/revamp of the classic Universal horror movie has much to recommend it, but being beholden to the classics hinders its effectiveness.

I will say this for The Wolfman: it is an unabashedly, unapologetically old school Universal horror movie. The movie wears its Victorian Gothic aspirations on its sleeve, and even its title screen is carved into a tombstone. A tombstone that is, naturally, dripping blood.
So too are its themes and central conflicts a throwback to those old horror films (the original Universal Wolf Man was released in 1941) which were themselves a throwback to Gothic horror of the late 19th century. Nowhere is this more apparent than in the mob scenes, where men bearing torches, guns and hunting dogs walk in silhouetted lines across hilltops and through forests in pursuit of the beast. There’s a hell of a lot of Victorian horror that’s all about the bad old days of primeval horror making one last violent stab in the modern age, about the individual dividing and conquering before succumbing to the mob, and that is something this new version of The Wolfman understands well.
But as starry-eyed as I am for such horror conventions, I wonder if they’re not a liability to new filmmakers who take a whack at them. For instance, I haven’t mentioned anything about the plot yet—because if you’re stepping foot into this theater in the first place, there’s a better-than-even chance you already know exactly how it’s going to go down. Lycanthropy, in the classic mold, is a tragic curse as much as anything else. The horror is not just in what the werewolf does to others, but what the werewolf does to the werewolf himself. So you know how it ends.
And, in fact, you pretty much know how it starts, too: actor Lawrence Talbot (Benicio Del Toro, at turns seething or wooden) returns to his family’s rural estate in England upon hearing of his brother’s grisly death at the hands of some savage beast. Talbot is reluctant to return, as the old homefront brings back uncomfortable memories of a cold father (Anthony Hopkins) and a beautiful mother who took her own life in Lawrence’s youth. It’s a place of bad memories, one Lawrence hoped to escape forever, but his mourning sister-in-law (Emily Blunt) is the first to tell him that no one escapes that house.
The rest you should be able to fill in yourself, which is where The Wolfman’s problem lies. “Origin” or “discovery” stories have an esteemed place in modern fiction, and when they relay something truly new—the world of wizards in Harry Potter, for instance—they are potent indeed. But when we’re dealing with the umpteenth rendition of werewolfism, it ultimately amounts to list-making: this version does react to silver and fire, is not in control of itself, et cetera. The movie’s second half moves past this retread into a larger story, but even then the conclusions are foregone. In great horror movies, a sense of inevitability can be a filmmaker’s ally. Here it is merely a beat sheet to be filled out.
To The Wolfman’s credit, it is considerably more organic about the “discovery” of a phenomenon we’ve seen rendered dozens of times on the big screen than one might guess, and it knows—as the best werewolf movies do—that the transformation scenes are “the money shot.” Special effects and makeup wizard Rick Baker manages to make the more-man-than-wolf werewolf not look ridiculous, which is something I would not have thought possible.
But there is absolutely nothing here that any fan of werewolf movies has not seen before.
A friend once defined horror as being “like a joke, but the punchline is the worst thing you can think of,” and that is largely true: you build tension and convince the audience you’re going one way before you jerk them into far worse territory than they could have imagined. The Wolfman, as beholden to its predecessors as it is an attempt to honor them, cannot break free of its bonds and give us anything new.